Monday, July 6, 2009

Prisoner number 88794 - languishing for a whole week in an immigration detention centre. The horror!

The following letter is reproduced from The Free Gaza Movement” website, and now appears to be in circulation on the Internet -- it first came to my attention that way. My comments will appear below the italicized text.

Letter from an Israeli Jail, by Cynthia McKinney

Saturday, 04 July 2009 13:47 Last Updated on Sunday, 05 July 2009 15:30 Written by Free Gaza Team

This is Cynthia McKinney and I'm speaking from an Israeli prison cellblock in Ramle. [I am one of] the Free Gaza 21, human rights activists currently imprisoned for trying to take medical supplies to Gaza, building supplies - and even crayons for children, I had a suitcase full of crayons for children. While we were on our way to Gaza the Israelis threatened to fire on our boat, but we did not turn around. The Israelis high-jacked and arrested us because we wanted to give crayons to the children in Gaza. We have been detained, and we want the people of the world to see how we have been treated just because we wanted to deliver humanitarian assistance to the people of Gaza.

At the outbreak of Israel's Operation ‘Cast Lead' [in December 2008], I boarded a Free Gaza boat with one day's notice and tried, as the US representative in a multi-national delegation, to deliver 3 tons of medical supplies to an already besieged and ravaged Gaza.

During Operation Cast Lead, U.S.-supplied F-16's rained hellfire on a trapped people. Ethnic cleansing became full scale outright genocide. U.S.-supplied white phosphorus, depleted uranium, robotic technology, DIME weapons, and cluster bombs - new weapons creating injuries never treated before by Jordanian and Norwegian doctors. I was later told by doctors who were there in Gaza during Israel's onslaught that Gaza had become Israel's veritable weapons testing laboratory, people used to test and improve the kill ratio of their weapons.

The world saw Israel's despicable violence thanks to al-Jazeera Arabic and Press TV that broadcast in English. I saw those broadcasts live and around the clock, not from the USA but from Lebanon, where my first attempt to get into Gaza had ended because the Israeli military rammed the boat I was on in international water ... It's a miracle that I'm even here to write about my second encounter with the Israeli military, again a humanitarian mission aborted by the Israeli military.
The Israeli authorities have tried to get us to confess that we committed a crime ... I am now known as Israeli prisoner number 88794. How can I be in prison for collecting crayons to kids?

Zionism has surely run out of its last legitimacy if this is what it does to people who believe so deeply in human rights for all that they put their own lives on the line for someone else's children. Israel is the fullest expression of Zionism, but if Israel fears for its security because Gaza's children have crayons then not only has Israel lost its last shred of legitimacy, but Israel must be declared a failed state.

I am facing deportation from the state that brought me here at gunpoint after commandeering our boat. I was brought to Israel against my will. I am being held in this prison because I had a dream that Gaza's children could color & paint, that Gaza's wounded could be healed, and that Gaza's bombed-out houses could be rebuilt.
But I've learned an interesting thing by being inside this prison. First of all, it's incredibly black: populated mostly by Ethiopians who also had a dream ... like my cellmates, one who is pregnant. They are all are in their twenties. They thought they were coming to the Holy Land. They had a dream that their lives would be better ... The once proud, never colonized Ethiopia [has been thrown into] the back pocket of the United States, and become a place of torture, rendition, and occupation. Ethiopians must free their country because superpower politics [have] become more important than human rights and self-determination.

My cellmates came to the Holy Land so they could be free from the exigencies of superpower politics. They committed no crime except to have a dream. They came to Israel because they thought that Israel held promise for them. Their journey to Israel through Sudan and Egypt was arduous. I can only imagine what it must have been like for them. And it wasn't cheap. Many of them represent their family's best collective efforts for self-fulfilment. They made their way to the United Nations High Commission for Refugees. They got their yellow paper of identification. They got their certificate for police protection. They are refugees from tragedy, and they made it to Israel only after they arrived Israel told them "there is no UN in Israel."

The police here have license to pick them up & suck them into the black hole of a farce for a justice system. These beautiful, industrious and proud women represent the hopes of entire families. The idea of Israel tricked them and the rest of us. In a widely propagandized slick marketing campaign, Israel represented itself as a place of refuge and safety for the world's first Jews and Christian. I too believed that marketing and failed to look deeper.

The truth is that Israel lied to the world. Israel lied to the families of these young women. Israel lied to the women themselves who are now trapped in Ramle's detention facility. And what are we to do? One of my cellmates cried today. She has been here for 6 months. As an American, crying with them is not enough. The policy of the United States must be better, and while we watch President Obama give 12.8 trillion dollars to the financial elite of the United States it ought now be clear that hope, change, and ‘yes we can' were powerfully presented images of dignity and self-fulfilment, individually and nationally, that besieged people everywhere truly believed in.

It was a slick marketing campaign as slickly put to the world and to the voters of America as was Israel's marketing to the world. It tricked all of us but, more tragically, these young women.

We must cast an informed vote about better candidates seeking to represent us. I have read and re-read Dr. Martin Luther King Junior's letter from a Birmingham jail. Never in my wildest dreams would I have ever imagined that I too would one day have to do so. It is clear that taxpayers in Europe and the U.S. have a lot to atone for, for what they've done to others around the world.

What an irony! My son begins his law school program without me because I am in prison, in my own way trying to do my best, again, for other people's children. Forgive me, my son. I guess I'm experiencing the harsh reality which is why people need dreams. [But] I'm lucky. I will leave this place. Has Israel become the place where dreams die?

Ask the people of Palestine. Ask the stream of black and Asian men whom I see being processed at Ramle. Ask the women on my cellblock. [Ask yourself:] what are you willing to do?

Let's change the world together & reclaim what we all need as human beings: Dignity. I appeal to the United Nations to get these women of Ramle, who have done nothing wrong other than to believe in Israel as the guardian of the Holy Land, resettled in safe homes. I appeal to the United State's Department of State to include the plight of detained UNHCR-certified refugees in the Israel country report in its annual human rights report. I appeal once again to President Obama to go to Gaza: send your special envoy, George Mitchell there, and to engage Hamas as the elected choice of the Palestinian people.

I dedicate this message to those who struggle to achieve a free Palestine, and to the women I've met at Ramle. This is Cynthia McKinney, July 2nd 2009, also known as Ramle prisoner number 88794.

Cynthia McKinney is controversial politician who is not shy about thumbing her nose at authority. She pushed her way past a security guard on Capitol Hill and allegedly assaulted him. She later apologized for her actions. Her father, who was also a politician, was heavily involved in the civil rights movement in Georgia and was reported to have made anti-Semitic remarks, to the effect, that the “Jews buy everybody”. I get the feeling she is a black Mel Gibson.

It is clear that long before she went to the Middle East she had her mind made up with respect to who is right and who is wrong in this conflict, and her mind has not been unduly influenced in that respect by a short stint in Israel’s immigration detention centre.

She is a great lover of conspiracy theories and was one of the early ones to jump on the “9/11 was an inside job” bandwagon. She later accused the authorities, in the wake of Katrina, of summarily executing 5,000 prisoners and secretly burying the bodies.

She wrote with approval to Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal after New York Mayor Guilani gave him back his $10 million donation when the Prince proceeded to lecture on U.S. foreign policy. McKinney focussed on the accusations of human rights breaches by Israel. Imagine, sympathizing with a leading Saudi on human rights violations. Perhaps Ms. McKinney should go to Arabia and rent a car and do a driving tour of the country. Then she will be able to compare the inside of a Saudi jail with that of Israel’s.

I am not to sure what to make of her comments about Ethiopian cellmates. Apparently, they are black. Who knew? They also are stateless, hence their housing and three squares a day courtesy of the Israeli taxpayers. Ethiopians are Christians, and apparently they are under some delusion (which McKinney quaintly calls dreams) that Israel is the homeland for Christians. Nope. It is the homeland for Jews.

It strikes me that the energetic Ms. McKinney has a lot to offer the United States in terms of working hard to find a solution to America’s illegal immigration policies and perhaps would be more effective at that than lecturing a foreign state on its immigration policies. But, then, that is what American politicians do best, telling other people how to live their lives.

There is an internationally approved naval blockade (also approved by the Palestinian Authority), managed by Israel, to prevent arms flow into Gaza. Twice Ms. McKinney’s vessel tried to run the blockade. On the second journey, the captain provided false information to the Cyprus port authorities as to the vessel’s destination (claiming Egypt), which secured port clearance for the departure, something that would have been denied if Gaza had been listed as the destination.

This is a woman who doesn’t like Jews, doesn’t like Zionists, doesn’t like Israel, and doesn’t respect authority as a matter of course. It is clear that the whole thing was staged as a publicity event. She wasn’t detained for carrying crayons to children; she was detained for blockade running. Until the Israeli navy apprehended the vessel and searched it, they could not be sure it was not carrying weapons. There was nothing done by Israel that was illegal. The same cannot be said for her.

She has been released by the Israelis and they have offered to deliver her humanitarian aid by land. Other than being temporarily detained, she has not been harmed in any way, and has the right to avail herself of the Israeli legal system to defend her (yes Virginia, unlike Hamas-run Gaza, Israel has a fully functioning legal system that even the Palestinians appreciate).

What I would recommend for Ms. McKinney’s next big adventure is delivering boxes of crayons to deprived black children in Darfur who are being systematically slaughtered by Arabs. I wonder how she will enjoy her experience being detained by the Jajanweed. They are not quite as punctilious about human rights as the Israelis, nor even the Saudis.

No comments: